Banker Lopez Gassler P.A.
  • Practice Areas
  • Attorneys
  • News
  • Careers
  • Locations
  • About Us
Get In Touch
Get In Touch
Back to latest news

Mark Tinker Obtains Reversal of Two Large Jury Verdicts

February 14, 2012

Mark Tinker, a BLG appellate attorney practicing in the firm’s St. Petersburg office, recently obtained reversals of two large jury verdicts in the Second District Court of Appeal. In the first case, our client was driving down a divided highway at night, at approximately 65 miles per hour, when a 15-year-old boy stepped out onto the roadway in front of her. She could not avoid hitting him, and he died from his injuries. His family sued for wrongful death, and at trial the boy’s friends who had witnessed the accident testified that he had been standing on the edge of the median when our client swerved over and hit him. Immediately following the accident, however, those same boys had told the investigating police officers that their friend had been texting on his cell phone, did not look up, and simply walked out onto the roadway directly in front of our client’s car. The judge excluded evidence of those statements from trial, ruling that since they had been provided to the investigating officers the accident report privilege applied. Mr. Tinker successfully convinced the appellate court that the privilege does not apply to mere eyewitnesses to an accident – only those who are involved and required to provide the statutory report. The court ordered a new trial, and this time the jury will have the opportunity to consider those statements.

In the second case, the plaintiff’s vehicle broke down at an intersection in the middle of the night. For several minutes, 3 of the 6 people in the car got out and tried to move it, but nobody attempted to warn traffic or even turn on the hazard lights. Our client was driving along, behind a van, when she approached that same intersection. She could see that the light was green, but could not see in front of the van. At the last second, the van swerved around the plaintiff’s stationary car. Our client couldn’t stop in time and hit it. The trial judge determined that our client was automatically at fault, since she hit the car from behind, and entered a directed verdict. On appeal, however, the Second District agreed that these facts rebutted that presumption and that the jury should have been permitted to determine if our client was truly at fault. The court accordingly ordered a new trial in that case, as well.

The opinions are available here:

  • February 08, 2012 / 2D11-1278 PDF
  • February 08, 2012 / 2D10-4595 PDF

If you have questions or have encountered similar issues, please call Mr. Tinker at (877) BLG-4321

Keep reading

February 29, 2012

The Verdict Is In For Richard Bowers and Jeffrey James

Read more
February 23, 2012

Congratulations to Michael Bird on his 12th jury trial

Read more
December 21, 2012

Congratulations to Roland Hermida

Read more
Banker Lopez Gassler P.A.
Locations

Tampa

501 E. Kennedy Boulevard
Suite 1700
Tampa, FL 33602

St. Petersburg

360 Central Avenue
Suite 1600
St. Petersburg, FL 33701

Orlando

315 East Robinson Street
Suite 680
Orlando, FL 32801

Fort Myers

4415 Metro Parkway
Suite 208
Fort Myers, FL 33916

Tallahassee

111 North Calhoun Street
Tallahassee, FL 32301

Fort Lauderdale

1200 South Pine Island Road
Suite 170
Plantation, FL 33324

Ocala

1900 S.E. 18th Avenue
Suite 300
Ocala, FL 34471

© 2025 Banker Lopez Gassler P.A., All Rights Reserved. |

Website Hosting & Web Development by RAD TECH

  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Compliance
  • Accessibility
  • LinkedIN
  • mail
All topics
  • All topics
  • Attorneys
  • Locations
  • Practice areas
  • News